| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team | |||
| #1 | Spencer Lee | IOWA | #1 Spencer Lee (IOWA) | #1 Spencer Lee | |||
| #2 | Liam Cronin | NEB | #2 Liam Cronin (NEB) | #2 Liam Cronin | |||
| #3 | Matt Ramos | PUR | #3 Matt Ramos (PUR) | #3 Matt Ramos | |||
| #4 | Eric Barnett | WIS | #4 Eric Barnett (WIS) | #4 Eric Barnett | |||
| #5 | Patrick McKee | MINN | #5 Patrick McKee (MINN) | #5 Patrick McKee | |||
| #6 | Michael DeAugustino | NU | #6 Michael DeAugustino (NU) | #6 Michael DeAugustino | |||
| #7 | Braxton Brown | MD | #7 Braxton Brown (MD) | #7 Braxton Brown | |||
| #8 | Dean Peterson | RUT | #8 Dean Peterson (RUT) | #8 Dean Peterson | |||
| #9 | Jack Medley | MICH | #9 Jack Medley (MICH) | #9 Jack Medley | |||
| #10 | Gary Steen | PSU | #10 Gary Steen (PSU) | #10 Gary Steen | |||
| #11 | Tristan Lujan | MSU | #11 Tristan Lujan (MSU) | #11 Tristan Lujan | |||
| #12 | Jacob Moran | IND | #12 Jacob Moran (IND) | #12 Jacob Moran | |||
| #13 | Maximo Renteria | ILL | #13 Maximo Renteria (ILL) | #13 Maximo Renteria | |||
| #14 | Andre Gonzales | OSU | #14 Andre Gonzales (OSU) | #14 Andre Gonzales | |||
| BYE | BYE | BYE | |||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||
| # () | # | ||||||