| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team |
| #1 | Aaron Brooks | PSU | #1 Aaron Brooks (PSU) | #1 Aaron Brooks |
| #2 | Trent Hidlay | NCST | #2 Trent Hidlay (NCST) | #2 Trent Hidlay |
| #3 | Lou Deprez | BING | #3 Lou Deprez (BING) | #3 Lou Deprez |
| #4 | Parker Keckeisen | UNI | #4 Parker Keckeisen (UNI) | #4 Parker Keckeisen |
| #5 | Hunter Bolen | VT | #5 Hunter Bolen (VT) | #5 Hunter Bolen |
| #6 | John Poznanski | RUT | #6 John Poznanski (RUT) | #6 John Poznanski |
| #7 | Brit Wilson | NIU | #7 Brit Wilson (NIU) | #7 Brit Wilson |
| #8 | Taylor Venz | NEB | #8 Taylor Venz (NEB) | #8 Taylor Venz |
| #9 | Jeremiah Kent | MIZZ | #9 Jeremiah Kent (MIZZ) | #9 Jeremiah Kent |
| #10 | Tate Samuelson | WYO | #10 Tate Samuelson (WYO) | #10 Tate Samuelson |
| #11 | Dakota Geer | OKST | #11 Dakota Geer (OKST) | #11 Dakota Geer |
| #12 | Nelson Brands | IOWA | #12 Nelson Brands (IOWA) | #12 Nelson Brands |
| #13 | Christopher Weiler | WIS | #13 Christopher Weiler (WIS) | #13 Christopher Weiler |
| #14 | Caleb Hopkins | CAMP | #14 Caleb Hopkins (CAMP) | #14 Caleb Hopkins |
| #15 | Layne Malczewski | MSU | #15 Layne Malczewski (MSU) | #15 Layne Malczewski |
| #16 | Max Lyon | PUR | #16 Max Lyon (PUR) | #16 Max Lyon |
| #17 | Owen Webster | MINN | #17 Owen Webster (MINN) | #17 Owen Webster |
| #18 | Alan Clothier | UNCO | #18 Alan Clothier (UNCO) | #18 Alan Clothier |
| #19 | Zach Braunagel | ILL | #19 Zach Braunagel (ILL) | #19 Zach Braunagel |
| #20 | David Key | NAVY | #20 David Key (NAVY) | #20 David Key |
| #21 | Dominic Ducharme | CSUB | #21 Dominic Ducharme (CSUB) | #21 Dominic Ducharme |
| #22 | Devin Kane | UNC | #22 Devin Kane (UNC) | #22 Devin Kane |
| #23 | Charles Small | HOF | #23 Charles Small (HOF) | #23 Charles Small |
| #24 | Rocky Jordan | OHST | #24 Rocky Jordan (OHST) | #24 Rocky Jordan |
| #25 | Matthew Waddell | CHAT | #25 Matthew Waddell (CHAT) | #25 Matthew Waddell |
| #26 | DeAndre Nassar | CSU | #26 DeAndre Nassar (CSU) | #26 DeAndre Nassar |
| #27 | Taylor Brown | ARMY | #27 Taylor Brown (ARMY) | #27 Taylor Brown |
| #28 | Dylan Ammerman | LEH | #28 Dylan Ammerman (LEH) | #28 Dylan Ammerman |
| #29 | Samuel Colbray | ISU | #29 Samuel Colbray (ISU) | #29 Samuel Colbray |
| #30 | Gregg Harvey | PITT | #30 Gregg Harvey (PITT) | #30 Gregg Harvey |
| #31 | Ryan Reyes | ORST | #31 Ryan Reyes (ORST) | #31 Ryan Reyes |
| #32 | Jhaquan Anderson | GW | #32 Jhaquan Anderson (GW) | #32 Jhaquan Anderson |
| #33 | Joe Accousti | SH | #33 Joe Accousti (SH) | #33 Joe Accousti |